The Laws of Fasts - The Laws of Tisha Be-av (1)
the laws of THE FESTIVALS
Rav David Brofsky
Shiur #24: The Laws of Fasts
The Laws of Tisha Be-av (1)
A few weeks ago, we introduced the four fast days mentioned by the
prophet Zekharia (8:19), who described them as "the fast of the fourth, fifth,
seventh, and tenth months." These four fasts commemorate the events leading to
and following the destruction of the first
The Mishna (Taanit 26a) enumerates the other tragedies that transpired on this day of misfortune:
tragic events befell our fathers
on the Ninth of Av
On the Ninth of Av it was
decreed that our fathers should not enter the Land, the
We noted a few weeks ago (http://vbm-torah.org/archive/moadim69/21-69moed.htm) that different themes may combine at times to comprise the nature of a single day. For example, Yom Kippur encompasses both the aspect of a moed, a festival, and a taanit tzibbur, a communal fast day. Indeed, we questioned whether the afternoon Torah reading of Yom Kippur reflected the taanit tzibbur aspect of the day, in which case only one who is fasting should receive an aliya, or the moed aspect of the day, in which case anyone may ascend to the Torah.
Similarly, it seems that different themes comprise the nature of Tisha Be-av.
On the one hand, as we discussed previously, the Talmud (Rosh Ha-Shana 18a) describes the severity of the fast of Tisha Be-av. Its strictness justified sending out messengers to notify those outside of Jerusalem regarding the day of the consecration of the new moon and the fast in its wake, as, unlike the other three communal fasts instituted after the destruction of the Beit Ha-mikdash, Tisha Be-av is always observed, as "multiple misfortunes befell us on that day."
Furthermore, unlike the other fast days, which are only observed partially, the fast of Tisha Be-av begins the night before, and one must abstain not only from eating, but from the other afflictions, i.e. washing and anointing, wearing shoes, and engaging in marital relations. In addition, the Torah portion of Parashat Va-Yechal (Shemot 32:11-14 and 34:1-10), which is read on the other fast days at Mincha, is read on Tisha Be-av as well. Tisha Be-av, therefore, represents the archetypical fast day.
On the other hand, Tisha Be-av is a day of mourning, of aveilut yeshana (Yevamot 43b), as the beraita cited by the Talmud (Taanit 30a) states: All mitzvot which apply to a mourner during the seven days of mourning apply on Tisha Be-av. We express this aspect of mourning throughout the day in our prayers and actions.
Over the next two shiurim, as we summarize the laws of Tisha Be-av, we will demonstrate how these two themes combine to create a new entity - Tisha Be-av.
Erev Tisha Be-av - Seudat Ha-Mafseket
The Talmud teaches that one should partake of a seuda mafseket, a final meal, before Tisha Be-av. The mishna (Taanit 26b), for example, states: On the eve of the Ninth of Av, one may not partake of a meal of two cooked foods, nor eat meat nor drink wine. Furthermore, the gemara (Taanit 30a) recounts the practice of R. Yehuda ben Illai:
On the eve of the Ninth of Av, they brought to him dry bread with salt and he would take his seat between the [baking] oven and the [cooking] stove and eat, and he would drink with a pitcher full of water and he would appear as if a near relative were lying dead before him.
Similarly, the Rambam (Hilkhot Taaniyot 5:9) writes, And he should eat it, and drink a pitcher of water, with worry, depression and weeping, as if a close relative is lying dead in from of him.
What may one eat at this meal? As we saw, the mishna prohibits eating meat and drinking wine at this meal, as these are important foods which arouse happiness. In addition, the mishna states that one should not eat two cooked foods. While the Acharonim discuss how to define two cooked foods, the Shulchan Arukh (552:6) simply writes that, when possible, one should eat dry bread with salt, along with water, for the seuda ha-mafseket. In addition, he (ibid. 5) reports that it is customary to eat lentils mixed with boiled eggs, which are a food of mourners.
The Rama adds that some eat hard-boiled eggs, which are also a food of mourners. Moreover, he writes that one should dip his bread into ashes, and, as the Mishna Berura (16) suggests based upon the practice of Rav as recorded by the Yerushalmi (Taanit 4:6), one should declare, This is the Tisha Be-av meal.
Since this simple meal would probably not tide a person over until the next day, the seuda ha-mafseket is usually preceded by another meal. The Rama (552:9) writes:
It is customary in these regions of Ashkenaz to eat a set meal before Mincha, and then afterwards to pray Mincha and then eat the seudat ha-mafseket. They are accustomed to increase this meal, in order that the fast should not be harmful, since we cease to eat during the day, like Yom Kippur.
the Magen Avraham (11) suggests that the custom to eat a large meal
before the seudat hamafseket may be rooted in a different idea. He
writes that since Tisha Be-av, during the time of the second
The Magen Avraham (10) also relates that some Acharonim (Levush, Bach, Shelah) disapprove of the custom recorded by the Rama and suggest eating this large meal, if necessary, before midday. The Eliya Rabba (12) cited by the Mishna Berura (22), however, writes that as long as ones intention are for the sake of Heaven, he may partake of a larger meal after noon, but he should leave room for the seudat ha-mafseket.
The Shulchan Arukh (553:1) rules that one may eat or drink after the seudat ha-mafseket until the onset of the fast, unless one explicitly accepts upon himself not to eat anymore. While the Rama adds that a mental acceptance does not constitute an acceptance, the Mishna Berura (2) writes that the Bach and Gra disagree; he therefore recommends stating explicitly that one intends to eat or drink until sunset.
The Acharonim mention a number of other customs associated with the seuda ha-mafseket.
First, one does not recite the birkat ha-mazon with a zimun. The Hagahot Maimoniyot (Hilkhot Taaniyot 5:7:30) writes:
Some of the great scholars of Ashkenaz and R. Sherira Gaon wrote as well, were accustomed not to recite the zimun with three during this meal; rather every individual should sit by himself, as it says, Let him sit alone and keep silence (Eicha 3:28). So, too, the Ri and R. Meshulam would recite the Grace after Meals by themselves even when sitting amongst a group of three [which would ordinarily mandate reciting the zimun]. It is proper for three people not to sit together in order that they should not become obligated in the zimun.
The Shulchan Arukh (552:8) rules accordingly, warning that three men should not sit together in order not to become obligated to recite the zimun. The Mishna Berura (19) adds that even if they did sit together, they should still not say the zimun.
Second, the Terumat Ha-deshen (1:151) writes that one should eat the seudat ha-mafseket while sitting on the ground, although he does not need to remove his shoes. The Shulchan Arukh (552:7) records this custom as well. Those who have difficulty sitting on the floor may sit on a chair, although they should preferable change their location (Kaf Ha-Chaim 552:38).
When Tisha Be-av falls out on Sunday, the seuda ha-mafseket is not held on Shabbat, and the restrictions mentioned above are not observed. One may eat meat and drink wine preceding the fast. However, one must stop eating before sunset (Shulchan Arukh and Rama, 552:10).
In addition to the laws of the seuda ha-mafseket, the Rama (553:2) writes:
It is customary not to learn [Torah] on the day before Tisha Be-av after midday, and therefore when Tisha Be-av falls out on Shabbat, we do not say Pirkei Avot. Similarly, one should not take walks on Erev Tisha Be-av.
While the Magen Avraham (7) upholds this custom and suggests that one should only learn those passages that are permitted for study on Tisha Be-av (554:1), others (Mishna Berura 8 and the Biur Halacha in the name of the Maharshal and Gra; Arukh Ha-Shulchan 553:4) challenge this custom, and even testify that they themselves (Maharshal, Mishna Berura) learn after midday before Tisha Be-av. Certainly when Tisha Be-av falls out on Shabbat, when one may even eat meat and drink wine, one who learns Torah until nightfall is in good company (Taz 553:2, Mishna Berura 10).
Finally, just as one does not recite Tachanun on Tisha Be-av (Shulchan Arukh 559:1), as Tisha Be-av is called a moed (Eicha 1:15), Tachanun is not recited at Mincha on Erev Tisha Be-av (ibid, 552:12).
The Fast of Tisha Be-av and the Other Fasts
As mentioned above, the fast of Tisha Be-av differs from the other three fast days. This is true quantitatively, regarding the length of the fast and the scope of its prohibitions, but also qualitatively. We noted that on the minor fast days, in contrast to Yom Kippur, cholim (the sick) are exempt from the fast. Therefore, not only does the halakha exempt a choleh she-ein bo sakana, a sick person whos life is not in danger, from the fast, there is also no need to eat in small quantities, chatzi shiur, as one must preferably do on Yom Kippur. Moreover, we learned that a pregnant or nursing woman is also fundamentally exempt from fasting, even though some are still accustomed to fast.
On Tisha Be-av, however, only the sick are exempt. Pregnant and nursing women are obligated to fast, unless fasting poses a danger to the mother or fetus (Shulchan Arukh 554:5). The Arukh Ha-shulchan (554:7) writes that pregnant (and nursing) women who are weak, and fasting may lead to illness, even if not life threatening, are exempt from fasting on Tisha Be-av. Therefore, a pregnant woman suffering from nausea, anemia (low hemoglobin), high or low blood pressure, or infection need not fast. Furthermore, a pregnant woman who fears, justifiably, that fasting may cause a miscarriage, or even bleeding or early contractions, must certainly break her fast.
Fasting may be especially difficult for a nursing woman, as nursing causes a woman to lose fluids; by not drinking, she risks not producing enough milk for her child. R. Chaim Mordechai Margulies (1780 1820), in his commentary to the Shulchan Arukh, the Shaarei Teshuva (554:6), writes that if fasting will affect the quality of the mothers milk or diminish it, which may pose a threat to the child, the mother may eat. Similarly, the Chazon Ish (see Piskei Teshuvot 554:6) would instruct nursing mothers who feared that they would not be able to produce enough milk to break their fast.
We discussed the laws of a sick person and those who must take medication on fast days in a previous lecture (http://vbm-torah.org/archive/moadim69/20-69moed.htm).
The Prohibitions of Tisha Be-av
Bathing and Anointing
Aside from eating and drinking, the Talmud (Taanit 30a) enumerates the other prohibitions of Tisha Be-av:
Our Rabbis have taught: All the restrictions that apply to the mourner apply on Tisha Be-av: eating, drinking, bathing, anointing, the wearing of shoes and marital relations, are forbidden thereon.
Although, as we mentioned above, this passage seems to equate the laws of Tisha Be-av with the laws of mourning, R. Soloveitchik noted that while a mourner may wash parts of his body in cold water, on Tisha Be-av one may not even immerse ones finger into cold water (Shulchan Arukh 554:7). The prohibition of rechitza (bathing), therefore, is defined by the days being a communal fast day, and not just a day of mourning.
Only washing for pleasure is prohibited; one may therefore wash his body if it is dirty (ibid. 9), after using the bathroom (Kitzur Shulchan Arukh 124:7), or for medicinal purposes (Shulchan Arukh 554:14). In the morning or upon waking, one may wash netilat yadayim as usual, pouring the water until the joints at the end of ones fingers (Shulchan Arukh 554:10). One may wash in a similar fashion before prayer (Mishna Berura 21). While preparing food, one may also wet ones hands (ibid. 19).
One who experiences extreme discomfort from lack of washing, known as an istenis, may wash his face (Mishna Berura 22).
In a previous lecture (http://vbm-torah.org/archive/moadim69/20-69moed.htm), we discussed brushing teeth on a communal fast day. We concluded that on an ordinary fast day, one who experiences discomfort from not rinsing his mouth or brushing his teeth may do so. On Tisha Be-av, however, as well as on Yom Kippur, we noted that the Posekim are more stringent. R. Moshe Feinstein (see R. Shimon Eiders Halachos of the Three Weeks, p. 19) even suggested that on Tisha Be-av washing out ones mouth may be prohibited because of rechitza (bathing). The Minchat Yitzchak (4:109) also prohibits rinsing ones mouth, but permits brushing teeth with powder in order to reduce discomfort. Furthermore, he believes that one may clean ones mouth in order to pray with cleanliness. The Mishna Berura (567:11), however, writes that even on Tisha Be-av, one who experiences great discomfort may wash out his mouth.
One may dry his hands on a towel and then use the damp towel to clean his eyes and face, as the towel isnt wet enough to impart enough water to wet something else (tofach al menat le-hatpiach) (Shulchan Arukh 554:11). (If one must actually clean ones eyes in the morning, it is permitted to do so normally, as it is no different than washing any other part of the body which has become soiled.) Furthermore, the Rama (ibid. 14) writes that one may pre-soak cloths before Tisha Be-av, remove them, and then use them to clean his face, hands, and feet. Even if ones intention is for pleasure, this is permitted because he already squeezed the water out of the cloths.
The gemara (above) also prohibits anointing for pleasure on Tisha Be-av (Shulchan Arukh 554:15). One may therefore not rub oil, cream, soap, or perfume into his skin. One may, however, rub oil on ones skin for medicinal purposes, or use Vaseline for chapped lips or bug repellents or anti-itch sprays. Moreover, one may use deodorant on Tisha Be-av (Biur Halakha 554 s.v. sikha), as ones intention is to prevent or remove odor. We will discuss whether this same leniency applies to Yom Kippur in a future lecture.
Wearing Leather Shoes on Tisha Be-av
In our upcoming lectures on Yom Kippur this fall, we will discuss whether the prohibition of neilat ha-sandal, wearing shoes, applies only to leather shoes or to other comfortable materials as well.
Briefly, while some Rishonim (Baal Ha-Maor Yoma 2a s.v. ve-sandal, for example) rule that one may not even wear comfortable wooden shoes on Tisha Be-av, and some prohibit wooden shoes but permit shoes of other materials (Rashi/Tosafot), most Rishonim (Rif, Yoma 2a; Ran ibid.; Rosh, Yoma 8:7; Tur 614) rule that only leather shoes are prohibited. Furthermore, while the Rambam (Hilkhot Shevitat Asor 3:7) does not explicitly prohibit non-leather shoes on Yom Kippur, he explains the permissibility of wrapping a cloth around ones feet, as the hardness of the ground reaches ones feet and he feels [as if] he is barefoot.
The Shulchan Arukh (554:16), ruling leniently, writes:
The wearing of shoes [which is prohibited] refers to [shoes of] leather. However, [shoes made of] a cloth, or wood, or cork, or rubber are permitted. Wooden shoes covered with leather are prohibited.
Some Acharonim (Mishna Berura 614:5 and Arukh Ha-shulchan 614:2-5, for example) suggest that one should be stringent and only wear shoes through which one can feel the ground. This debate may be especially important nowadays, when many people wear comfortable shoes made from synthetic materials.
Marital Relations on Tisha Be-av
The gemara (above) prohibits marital relations on Tisha Be-av, just as they are prohibited for a mourner. R. Yosef Karo, in his Beit Yosef (554) and in the Shulchan Arukh (554:18), cites the Hagahot Mordechai (Moed Katan), who rules that one should not even sleep in the same bed with ones wife on the night of Tisha Be-av. The Mishna Berura (27) writes, based upon the Magen Avraham, that one should avoid all physical contact with ones wife in the evening, as on Yom Kippur, although during the day it is permitted. Some (Kitzur Shulchan Arukh 124:12) prohibit physical contact during the day as well. The Taz (615:16) disagrees completely and permits physical contact even at night on Tisha Be-av, and during the day on Yom Kippur. Seemingly, all would agree that affectionate contact should be avoided during the entire day of Tisha Be-av.
Next week we will continue our study of the laws of Tisha Be-av.