Introduction to Massekhet Sukka
the Study of Talmud (5773)
Yeshivat Har Etzion
Masechet Sukka -01: Introduction
by Rav Ezra Bick
This year we will be mostly studying the third chapter of Masechet Sukka in the Introduction to Talmud course. Masechet Sukka naturally discusses the laws of the holiday of Sukkot, specifically the sukka itself, and the mitzva of the four species, lulav, etrog, hadas, and arava. The first two chapters deal mainly with the construction of the sukka, and the third chapter with the mitzva of the four species. We will begin our learning with the end of the second chapter, where the Talmud begins to discuss the fulfillment of the mitzva to dwell in a sukka, after it has been properly constructed.
The rest of this week's mailing is basically a repetition of the introduction to the course that was sent last year, for the benefit of those who are joining us for the fist time. The actual learning of Masechet Sukka will begin next week.
This is a text-based course. We will be mostly concentrating on learning how to read and understand the Talmudic text. The optimal way to do this is to have the traditional page of printed Talmud, what is called "tzurat hadaf," in front of you as we go over the text. This is important for a number of reasons. Firstly, if you continue to advance in your learning skills, that is the form of Talmud that you will be using. Secondly, the printed "daf" contains a great deal of additional material that we will be using, and learning how to use these aids is an important part of learning Talmud.
In any event, the shiur will contain the English translation of the Talmudic text under discussion, as well as a version of the original Hebrew/Aramaic text. Nonetheless, it is highly preferable that you obtain an edition of this Masechet in printed form, or at least photocopies of the relevant pages. Each week, I will provide a link for a copy of the printed page, courtesy of E-daf.com.
The best edition of the Talmud with English translation is the ArtScroll edition, which also includes a running explanations and commentary. It provides, in my opinion, important tools for helping one learn on ones own, which is the goal of this course. Individual volumes can be purchased (the entire Talmud is tens of volumes).
So, in order of preference, here are your possibilities:
1. Obtain a copy of the ArtScroll edition of Masechet Sukka.
2. Obtain a standard Hebrew/Aramaic edition of the masechet.
3. Download each week the copy of the "daf" which we will be learning.
4. Rely on the text of the lesson that you receive by email (not recommended).
Each week, we will read and explain a short section of the Talmud. The lesson will begin with the text, and you should try to read the text and understand it on your own. In the course of the explanation, I will insert "pauses" to allow you to answer questions or fulfill other assignments. Obviously, there is no way for me to actually ensure that you are following my directions. But again, if you want to get the most out of this course, you will not merely read it. Unlike all the other courses in the VBM, this one is really based on our working together, so it is very important that you follow the suggestions and instructions in the text. The true goal is not to acquire the content of a few lines of Talmud, but to begin to learn "how to learn."
The shiur this year will be posted in html format. The link will be sent to you by mail message, which, when opened, can be read in a web browser.
The following is basically the same introduction that was sent to the Introduction to Talmud course previously. Many of you have either already read it, or are familiar with the basic concepts and ideas from other sources. Still, in order to get started, we have to get past this point for all the students.
introductory lesson to a course entitled "Introduction to the Study of Talmud"
might seem redundant. The answer,
however, is embedded in the title of the course. This is not an introduction to the
Talmud, but an introduction to the STUDY of Talmud. If I were writing an introduction to the
Talmud, we could easily reach an entire year's worth of introductory lectures,
which I think would in fact be interesting and informative, without ever
reaching the actual learning of the text.
However, most of the important information included in those lectures
would not really be appreciated until we got down into the workings of text
itself. In fact, for nearly all of
the history of Talmud study, the only way one learned "how to learn" was by
jumping into the text, a text that for thousands of years has been called the
For this course, I am assuming no background at all, a clean slate, so to speak. Some of these points may be known to many of you, and for that I beg your forbearance.
1. A Word or Two on Text.
Talmud consists of two distinct primary texts, the Mishna and the Gemara. Surrounding these two, there exists a huge literature, spanning 1800 years and thousands of books, of commentaries, summations, and extended discussions, which continues to this day. When we study Talmud, we are in fact addressing that entire literature, though obviously much of it must wait for advanced levels of learning. But even on the beginning level of this course we are not studying a BOOK, but rather a literature, which in fact precedes the actual Talmud, and of course extends beyond it. From a literary point of view, the Talmud is the basis and core text, most importantly because it is authoritative, and hence is the starting-point for any subsequent discussion.
The Mishna is printed as a distinct work, and often studied separately. In editions of the Talmud, the Mishna is printed together with the Gemara as a unit, and that is the way we shall be studying.
The Mishna is a halakhic code. It presents a set of rulings on all halakhic matters, in all areas of life. True to the nature of the Oral Law, it is not generally written in a monolithic manner, but rather preserves controversies and disagreements, hundreds of them, from the authorities of the Mishnaic period, roughly the first century and a half of the Common Era. Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi, the head of Palestinian Jewry, compiled the present form of the Mishna and thereby summarized and codified the halakhic rulings of the previous centuries. This was the first code of Jewish law.
The Gemara is
the record of two centuries of discussion, argument, elucidation, and
controversy surrounding the text of the Mishna, first in the
The previous paragraph has illustrated, inter alia, an important technical aspect of our study. The Mishna is written in Hebrew (in a dialect that is called by the linguists, not surprisingly, Mishnaic Hebrew). The Talmud is written in a mixture of Hebrew and Aramaic. Both are filled with hundreds of technical terms, both legal and logical, which are often difficult to translate. I shall of course translate or explain them as they come up, but we shall prefer the use of the original terms even in an English-language lecture. Our goal, again, is to study text, and to enter into the world of Talmudic study. Every Talmudic discussion consists of a "hava amina," literally, "I would have said," and a "maskana," a conclusion. A standard question when reading a position that is rejected by the Gemara is to ask, "what was the hava amina?"; i.e., what was the (ultimately rejected) understanding of the subject that underlay the opening position expressed in the gemara. Once you answer that question, the teacher asks the opposite question - "now tell me what is the maskana," meaning not the conclusion itself, but the change in logic that caused the change in position.
I assume that
Aramaic, and perhaps Mishnaic Hebrew is not a language in which most of you are
fluent. All editions of the Talmud
are accompanied by running explanatory commentaries, the most important of which
is that of Rashi (R. Shlomo Yitzchaki, 11th century
(The Talmud as a whole is usually printed in 20 very large volumes. The Schottenstein translation is much larger, with each normal volume of the Hebrew original divided into three translated volumes with commentary. Buying the whole set will make a significant dent in your bank account, but will enrich you immensely. For the purpose of this course, buying ONE volume - Masechet Sukka - will suffice. In any event, each page of Talmudic text will be posted on the web, so you can manage to get by without spending a penny.)
While I recommend a translation, and will translate myself as we continue and provide a glossary, the text we are studying will be the original. The ability to read the Hebrew words is assumed. I shall be constantly referring to the Hebrew and Aramaic text (with explanation and translation); for again, the purpose is to introduce you to the study of Talmud as all students of Talmud study it, which is the original, with the traditional commentaries (all of which are not available in translation in any event).
2. The "daf" - a page of Talmud
The Hebrew word "daf" means page. In the tradition of Talmudic learning, it means a leaf; i.e., a physical page, which of course has two sides. To distinguish the two, we use a postscript, so that the page we are beginning on is daf 25a.
A scan of this daf can be seen at http://www.vbm-torah.org/talmud10/sukka25a.gif
Take a look at this daf. You will see up on the left-hand corner the letters chaf-heh, which means 25. (On the web scan, this is circled in red and marked with the number 1). In all standard editions of the Talmud (but not the Schottenstein), the first side of a page (i.e., 25a) is always on the left side of the open volume. The reverse side (25b) does not have any Hebrew page number at all, but for several centuries has had an Arabic numeral, in this case "50" (Notice that the Arabic numerals refer to sides, while the Hebrew ones to full pages. Why? That's just the way it is!).
Running down the middle of the page, in block Hebrew letters, is the text of the Talmud. On the page we are examining, a new mishna begins on the tenth line of the page (number 2). This is where we will begin studying next week. Two lines later, we find the letters "gimel-mem" (number 3), which is the abbreviation for "gemara." This is where the gemara discussion of this mishna begins. The gemara discussion of this mishna will continue for 2 pages, but there is no rule for the relative length of a mishna and its gemara.
On either side of the main text are two commentaries. On the right side is the running commentary of Rashi, R. Shlomo Yitzchaki, who lived in Champagne in the 11th century. Rashi is the primary commentary on both the Talmud and the Bible, and every talmudic discussion will begin with his interpretation of the talmudic text. The lettering in the standard editions of the Talmud is in a different script than that of the central Talmud text. This script is popularly called "Rashi-script," although it was not used by Rashi himself. It is a printer's version of the cursive script used by scribes in the Middle Ages. If you are not familiar with it, it may be difficult to read, but I hope you will quickly get used to it.
On the left side is a commentary consisting of several extended comments, each beginning with the Talmudic text to which it refers marked in bold letters. This is the "Tosafot," which simply means addenda. In true Talmudic tradition, the Tosafot do not have one particular author, but record the discussion in the French (and German) schools of Rashi's disciples for the next four or five generations. Very often, the starting point for these discussions was the commentary of Rashi, generally beginning with a question which will give rise to an alternate explanation.
Gemara with Rashi and Tosafot is the bread-and-butter of Talmudic study. We are aiming at reaching that level.
The page contains an additional outer ring of various glosses of later authorities, citations to halakhic codes, and cross-references to other Talmudic passages. Aside from this, there are thousands of books that continue the discussion. In our study, we shall examine, occasionally, some of the more important of these additional commentaries.
An extensive and detailed account of these and other features of the talmudic daf can be found at:
which probably has even more than you might want to know at this stage. If you take a look at the daf presented on Professor Segal's webpage, you will see that it looks exactly like the one we are studying, even though it is from a completely different section of the Talmud. The page layout has been standard for nearly five hundred years, with some additions.
Try reading the mishna now, with Rashi, and using the translation, if you have one. We shall begin with this mishna in next week's shiur.